How legal aid cuts left me and family in meltdown
After the council withdrew his housing benefit, Ian's life went into meltdown. Ian has blogged about his experience of battling legal issues without the help of legal aid, to raise awareness of the wide-reaching consequences.
Ian is one of the many Mind campaigners supporting us in our fight for a better deal for people with mental health problems.
For seven years leading up to August 2016, I received Employment and Support Allowance (ESA) because my PTSD meant that I was unable to work. But that August, I began to do some work for my wife’s business. Even though it was unlikely to make any real difference to increasing our income, it was a good opportunity for me to do something positive for my mental health, and something I felt well enough to do. As I was then working I started receiving Working Tax Credits instead of ESA, which I was expecting.
"The local council also stopped our Housing Benefit."
However, the local council also stopped our Housing Benefit immediately, even though our low income meant we were financially eligible and we relied upon it to make ends meet. They asked me for a lot of information about the business and about our finances, and I gave them as much as I possibly could. But they decided what I had provided wasn’t enough and continued to ask for more information – some of it we didn’t have and some of it we could not provide because it was an invasion of clients’ privacy. As a result the council refused to reinstate the benefit.
This left my family over £1000 per month below the breadline. My family’s income was halved and we had to borrow money from family and friends to get by. My two young children missed their birthdays and went without Christmas.
"Changes to legal aid criteria mean there is no support for benefits issues."
I started an appeal against the council’s decision and it took 13 months to even get to a hearing. I couldn’t get any financial help to contribute to the cost of finding a lawyer because changes to legal aid criteria mean there is no support for benefits issues. As my wife and I couldn’t afford a lawyer ourselves we were left completely on our own and I ended up having to represent myself at the hearing.
The stress was incredible, trying to live below the breadline and fight a case without legal advice or representation. My family literally went into meltdown. I was driven out of my own home by the disruption and I ended up spending time in our horrible local homeless shelter as a result.
"The stress of it all caused my own mental health to fall to a desperate level."
The stress of it all caused my own mental health to fall to a desperate level. In the end I had a breakdown the night before the hearing, I became catatonic and I did not know how I could manage to go. Fortunately a family friend came and got me up, drove me to the hearing and supported me, but I still shook from head to toe throughout the process.
Even though I was relatively lucky at the hearing in that the judge was quite understanding, having to represent myself and being up against a trained professional on the other side was intimidating. I was at a huge disadvantage and the respondent took maximum advantage of the situation, repeatedly harassing me and being discriminatory in regard to my condition.
In the end, I did win my case. The judge described the council's actions as illegal and unreasonable and said that I had done everything right. We were back paid nearly £15,000 for the months we had not received housing benefit.
This was a huge relief but doesn't get rid of the fact that for over a year, we had no money to pay for anything. It really was a miracle that we survived, both financially and emotionally.
Information & Support
When you’re living with a mental health problem, or supporting someone who is, having access to the right information - about a condition, treatment options, or practical issues - is vital. Visit our information pages to find out more.
Share your story with others
Blogs and stories can show that people with mental health problems are cared about, understood and listened to. We can use it to challenge the status quo and change attitudes.